Rent vs Buy Calculator

Compare the real costs of renting and buying over time. The comparison factors in the mortgage, taxes, maintenance, opportunity cost and equity build-up, not just the monthly payment. Move the sliders and the result updates as you go.

Renting

Monthly
$2,800per month

Buying

One-time and monthly
$750,000
$50,0006.7% down
First-time home buyer
Additional assumptionsOptional: appreciation, investment returns, rising ownership costs and selling costs

These feed the buy cost, equity and opportunity cost figures in the verdict below. The defaults are reasonable long-run estimates, so only adjust them if you have a different view.

Time horizon
After 5 years, buying is
$0worse than renting
  • Total rent cost
  • Total buy cost (net)
  • Equity after selling costs
  • Opportunity cost of your upfront cash

Monthly cost comparison

Year 1
Renting total
Buying total
  • Mortgage (principal and interest)
  • Taxes + insurance + condo fees + utilities
  • Maintenance reserve

Buying, upfront costs

One-time
  • Down payment
  • Ontario and Toronto land transfer tax
  • Lawyer and closing
  • CMHC premium (rolled into the mortgage)
  • Ontario sales tax on the CMHC premium (paid at closing)
  • Total cash needed upfront

Ready to run your own numbers with a real agent?

Renting or buying in Toronto: common questions

Is it better to rent or buy in Toronto?

It depends mostly on how long you plan to stay. Buying carries large upfront costs (land transfer tax, legal fees) and selling costs at the end, so renting usually comes out ahead over a short stay and buying over a long one. The calculator compares the two for any period from 3 to 25 years.

What costs does the comparison include?

For buying: the mortgage, property tax, insurance, condo fees, utilities, a maintenance reserve, land transfer tax, legal and closing costs, CMHC insurance where it applies and the cost of selling. For renting: the rent over the period. Home equity at the end is counted in favour of buying.

What is opportunity cost in a rent or buy comparison?

It is what your down payment and closing costs could have earned if you had invested them instead of putting them into a home. The calculator counts it as a cost of buying.

Do first-time buyers come out ahead sooner?

First-time buyers pay less upfront: the land transfer tax rebates are worth up to $4,000 in Ontario and up to $4,475 in Toronto. Set first-time home buyer to Yes to include them.

Estimates only. Actual results depend on interest rates, appreciation, market conditions, taxes and individual circumstances. Not financial advice. How the numbers are worked out: mortgage payments use Canadian semi-annual compounding at one rate for the whole period, and they stop once the mortgage is paid off. CMHC insurance is added to the mortgage when the down payment is under 20%: 2.8% of the mortgage with 15% to 19.99% down, 3.1% with 10% to 14.99%, 4.0% with 5% to 9.99%, plus 0.2 of a percentage point when the amortization is longer than 25 years. The 8% Ontario sales tax on the CMHC premium is paid in cash at closing and is counted in the upfront costs. Minimum down payment is 5% of the first $500,000 and 10% of the rest below $1.5 million; homes at $1.5 million or more need 20% down and cannot have CMHC insurance. Land transfer tax uses the Ontario brackets, and the same brackets again for the Toronto tax when the box is ticked, with the City’s higher rates above $3 million. When first-time home buyer is set to Yes, the Ontario tax is reduced by up to $4,000 and the Toronto tax by up to $4,475. Lawyer and closing costs are set at $2,000. Rent and the renter’s utilities rise each year by the annual rent increase. The buyer’s property taxes, home insurance, condo fees and utilities rise each year by the annual increase in ownership costs, and the maintenance reserve rises with the home’s value. Opportunity cost is what the upfront cash would have earned if it had been invested instead. Equity is the home’s value at the end of the period, minus the mortgage balance and minus the selling costs.